Grade 12 law students from Rainbow District School Board and Near North District School Board donned legal gowns to prosecute and defend an individual charged with “second degree murder,” contrary to s. 235(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada at this year's Mock Trial Competition.
The event was held on June 11 at the Sudbury Courthouse.
Some 70 students from Confederation Secondary School, Espanola High School, Lasalle Secondary School, Lockerby Composite School, Lo-Ellen Park Secondary School, Sudbury Secondary School and Chippewa Secondary School competed for the Hennessy Cup - named after Madame Justice Patricia C. Hennessy, a driving force for the Mock Trial Competition since its inception in 2001.
The Hennessy Cup was awarded to Lockerby Composite School’s Michaela Antonioni, Calli Evans, Katie Koski, Zander Kasunich, Chloe Simpson, Maia Matheson and Ella Smith.
Silver medals were presented to Espanola High School Team No. 2 including Trinity Wabegijig-Cooper, Owen Bourcier, Alexa Hunt, Evanlee Yarkie and Isabella St. Michel.
“Year after year, we see an impressive group of students who have worked hard to prepare for the Mock Trial Competition. Students acquire and develop portable skills through their preparation regardless of their ultimate career path,” said Regional Senior Justice Karen Lische of the Ontario Court of Justice. “The process allows students a glimpse into the law as a profession and to get a sense as to what it might feel like to be involved in the criminal justice system as a witness. Through this process, students have the opportunity to better appreciate the presumption of innocence.”
The Hennessy Cup is part of the OJEN/OBA Competitive Mock Trials - a provincial program of the Ontario Bar Association and the Ontario Justice Education Network. The OBA and OJEN support competitions like the Hennessy Cup throughout the province. Teams competing in Sudbury use the same case scenario and format as other teams throughout Ontario.
This year, presiding Judges were Regional Senior Justice Karen L. Lische, Ontario Superior Court Justice K. Erin Cullin, retired Ontario Court Justice Randall Lalande, Justice of the Peace Erin Olesen-Schinke, and Ontario Superior Court Justice Patricia Hennessy.
Leading up to the event, 18 lawyers and articling students from the Greater Sudbury area, as well as three lawyers from North Bay, volunteered their time to assist and coach students as they prepared their cases. The local office of the Ministry of the Attorney General is also a strong supporter and accommodates the competition in the courthouse with both facilities and staff. To the extent possible, the students enjoy an authentic learning experience presenting their cases in actual courtrooms assisted by experienced court staff.
Students participated in trials throughout the day with the top two performing teams participating in the Championship Trial. In addition to the Hennessy Cup, a number of other awards were presented. Students on each team determined the recipient of the team’s “Most Valuable Player” who exemplified leadership excellence.
"The mock trial judges strive to give each student individualized feedback with the hopes of enhancing their experience,” said Justice Erin Cullin of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. “There is an award for Team Civility as the civility of counsel is exceptionally important, even in an adversarial system. Other awards include Best Witness, Best Advocate Crown and Best Advocate Defence. I applaud the students, the teachers and the lawyer coaches for their efforts.”
Students could also win individual awards, sponsored by local law firms.
The winners are:
Lacroix Lawyers Best Advocate Crown Award:
Abigail Pitre, Sudbury Secondary School Team No. 1
Weaver Simmons LLP Best Advocate Defence Award:
Ethan MacLellan, Confederation Secondary School
Miller Maki LLP Best Witness Award:
Owen Bourcier, Espanola High School Team No. 2
Edward J. Conroy Q.C. Team Civility Award:
Confederation Secondary School
